SILENCE

THOUGHTS ON SILENCE IN THE MUSIC INDUSTRY

In the music business, silence can be a warning – the sound of no one caring. Your song’s not streaming, the world’s moved on without you.

But it can be a weapon too - a defence against intrusive media. The ability to say nothing, to release nothing, to go house hunting in Santa Catarina, or plan a new vodka brand.

Silence can also be a way of controlling a record company’s demands without getting into a major conflict. It can break the rules without announcing it’s doing so. It disrupts the natural order of business. Normal industry procedure requires a steady supply of content — interviews, apologies, explanations. Silence refuses them.

Masters of silence know how much it can irritate people. David Bowie was brilliant at it – one minute all over the place, the next totally absent, sometimes for a year at a time. His knack of withdrawing from the industry’s daily churn was soon copied by other artists. Kate Bush built a legend out of silence. And Sade, after three years of nonstop success, disappeared for eight years before coming back with a hit album. Then repeated the trick; this time with a break of ten years.

Silence can be a great way to make noise. If an artist is expected to speak, then disappears, it’s a foolproof provocation. Fans speculate and journalists invent motives. The same’s true if they refuse to post. In a digital era, silence becomes confrontational, which is precisely why it works. It breaks the unspoken contract that visibility must be constant.

Silence has no algorithm. Record companies hate it because it puts them totally in the hands of the artist, not a place they like to be. So they tell artists that silence is career suicide; that the modern audience must never be allowed to feel a pause – not only should they post every week, but singles must flow unceasingly.

Most artists conform, some don’t. Frank Ocean, for instance, seems particularly well adjusted to silence – several years of it, then more hits. Adele disappears, then comes back when she’s ready - and the world stops. Kendrick Lamar goes missing for five years - then, when he’s nearly forgotten, drops his best album.

To stay silent that long, you have to be sure people really care about you. Even then, it’s a risk. The algorithm forgets you, the audience finds someone else, the manager looks for new acts, and the label finds things to put out - remixes, reissues, podcasts. Anything but silence.

It also applies to the music. Pop is notoriously unforgiving when it comes to allowing a moment of silence. Songs that manage to slip one in are extraordinarily rare. In the 1960s, on Shapes of Things, the Yardbirds brilliantly anticipated today’s EDM drops with the break before Jeff Beck’s scorching guitar solo. On Eric Carmen’s All By Myself, there’s total silence before the drum-fill leading into the final soul-searing chorus - only half a second of it, but enough to treble the impact of what follows. And of course, there’s Phil Collins’ In the Air Tonight, with its famous gateed drum-fill. But the real high spot comes thirty seconds earlier when the synth suddenly scoops upwards - harmonically unresolved - then drops to nothing.

The heir to that silence is the ice-cold drop on Swedish House Mafia’s Greyhound. This isn’t a pause in the classical sense, not a fermata or caesura. It’s a death-flash. A fraction of a second when nothing exists.

In all these instances, the exciting thing about the silences is what happens just after they end. But there’s a different type too. Like the silence after The Beatles A Day in the Life, when the final note dies, bleeding into the room. Not emptiness, but completion. The sound of something having fully happened.

That’s the silence that frightens artists. It’s the reason they keep on touring into their eighties. Trying to avoid the silence of a career fully played out.

TO SUBSCRIBE, CLICK AND LEAVE YUR EMAIL

REGULAR UPDATES - AND IT’S FREE