37 Comments
User's avatar
Iain Stewart's avatar

And ill add Steve Jones, the power and glory, edge and attack of the Pistols

Highland Fleet Lute's avatar

One man orchestra. Even in the early days.

"Can't play", my arse....

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mq5pEBJpUq0

Michael Anyon's avatar

Too right Iain. I was hoping Simon might’ve given him a mention 🎸❤️

One In The Pipe's avatar

Stone Gossard. The anchor of Pearl Jam. The last time i saw PJ he stood far stage left, the guy barely even had a spotlight on him, and he was the foundation for everything.

Two more (slightly) unsung guitar giants:

Billy Duffy The Cult

Elliott Easton The Cars

Jon Gill #MadeOnAMobile's avatar

I realise I’m adding to a list which, essentially, you’ve scrapped… and I 💯 agree, and this was a great post. But to add to what you’ve more than adequately articulated… Black Francis and Joey Santiago of the Pixies. On their own they are great, exceptional players. Together, they transcend 🤷🏼‍♂️

Bebop Boy's avatar

Cool pic!

Gus's avatar

Of those that are still alive, Eric Johnson or Richie Kotzen.

Geoff CARTER's avatar

Rory Gallagher

Bruce McDonald's avatar

I’m too mercurial in my moods & tastes. There’s a reason why I say…

Things I Hate

1. Lists

Jana Yell's avatar

Brilliant read! Always enjoy your insights..some bit of an eye opener and I’ve worked in music a very long time.

The Elysian Lovers's avatar

Yes, as you say the list could go on forever, so many outstanding guitar architects! A personal fave of ours: Lindsay Buckingham 🌻

Simon Napier-Bell's avatar

So many personal faves. That's why I didn't even attempt to make a choice.

Simon Napier-Bell's avatar

All of them wonderful - I agree

Bobby Colomby's avatar

A friend gave me your book: The Business. Half way through I noticed that another friend had written a blurb on the back cover. I subscribed to your Substack. Every single one of your observations that I've read so far are spot on and come from a very unique and interesting point of view. Your writing is superb.

Simon Napier-Bell's avatar

Thanks for the compliment - please help spread the word.

Michael Gerard Mc Fadden's avatar

Paul Kossoff , Edge , Bolan at times

Simon Napier-Bell's avatar

When we talk about Bolan we need to think back to Eddie Cochran too

Michael Gerard Mc Fadden's avatar

The Orange Gretsch & The Orange Gibson Les Paul 💚💚

Peter hall's avatar

Jimmy Page has given me the most pleasure and astonishment of any guitarist- he has reached higher and further than anyone else with the instrument. And no mistakes - flawless execution and production. Paul McCartney must also be included in the list and of course Johnny Marr.

Simon Napier-Bell's avatar

Trouble is - the list can go on forever. So many more I'd like to mention.

hmmm...Daniel B. James's avatar

A great piece Simon. Thank you as ever. It's not a fair question. Mind you Keith is pretty damn good :-)

Dani’el Kannan's avatar

Just like who is the greatest rock manager ?

Kev Nixon's avatar

No one cares…

Bobby Colomby's avatar

Another thing... should we ever meet... we could spend days sharing stories of our experiences.

Simon Napier-Bell's avatar

That conversation might never end.